The ChangePath Blog

Thinking about Australian charity

Australian charity donation platforms compared (Updated)

ChangePath isn’t just a charity assessment website. We’re a not-for-profit ourselves. In order to continue to exist in any kind of sustainable form, we need to be able to accept donations. You might assume this is a relatively easy task (every charity needs some way of raising money) but there’s a blizzard of potential web platforms out there competing to do so. To help small charities cut through this thicket of marketing, we’ve put together a short guide to the major Australian platforms, what they’re good at, and how to decide between them.

As you would imagine, these platforms aren’t directly comparable – some offer services that others do not, or have a different focus. The solutions that a large charity would be looking for are very different to what a newly established charity is interested in. For this article we’re looking at the sector from the perspective of a small Australian not-for-profit looking to raise money because, well, that’s what we are.

(Note: This article will only be good for a few months. Web payment platforms change their prices and offerings so often that anything published on the topic will quickly be out of date. Also, I’m not getting paid by any of these guys.)

Update Sept 2017: Added two new platforms, updated all links. If you would like your platform to be listed in this article, just let me know in the comments.

 

What donation platforms do

Let’s take a step back. What do payment platforms actually do, and how are they helpful to your non-profit? Obviously, not all platforms offer all services, but these are some of the basic facilities that many provide.

Hosting donation pages

The bread-and-butter of many online payment platforms, they will host a donations page on your behalf, collect donations, and send the proceeds to you. This means you don’t need to worry about receipts or credit card compliance. They do, however, generally take a cut of the donations you receive.

Allowing others to fundraise on your behalf

Larger platforms will often allow members of the public to create personal fundraising pages that collect money for your cause. This allows your supporters to get more actively involved and can be an entirely new donation stream. It’s especially good for social media, as it allows supporters to reach out to their friends and family easily.

Hosting events

A newer addition is that some platforms will actually host entire events, occasionally handling registration and ticketing as well as donations and a web presence.

 

Sidenote: State-by-state registration

Charities hoping to fundraise across Australia need to register for permission to fundraise in every state and territory they hope to do so.

This is generally free, but does require a bit of paperwork and means you must have an auditor. Some more stringent states (such as WA) require all office-holders to provide current police checks.

A comprehensive guide to fundraising legislation can be found at the Funding Centre.

In general, it pays to ask whether you will need to apply in any particular state – online fundraising especially is a bit of a grey area, and many states have unwritten rules about what they consider to be in-state fundraising and what they don’t. In general, it seems like you should have fundraising permission in at least one state (preferably your home state) and then check with all the other states whether you actually need to get their license. We found that WA and QLD are both happy to waive the requirement for a license as long as you don’t do any direct marketing to their residents, but it’s a fine line. Just send an email to confirm within your particular circumstances – better to have it in writing from the source.

Comparing charity payment platforms

This is not an exhaustive list of payment platforms, but it covers the major ones that accept Australian dollars as standard 1.

The way these platforms generally make their money is by taking a cut of all donations that pass through their doors. As you’ll see, the amounts they charge vary but they’re often around 5%. They can also charge fees to join or annually.

Also, because I don’t want anyone to think that I’m implicitly endorsing anyone, they’re in alphabetical order.  (I’ll explicitly endorse some platforms at the end, don’t worry).

 

DonatePlanet

Fees: Annual fee of $95

Cut:  5.5% fee, plus 2.2% credit card fees

Who can register: You don’t need to be ACNC registered, or even an organisation – you can raise funds directly through an appeal linked to the Donate Planet Foundation Limited.

Pricing information: https://donateplanet.com/faqs/

Website: https://donateplanet.com/

DonatePlanet are a Sydney-based not-for-profit that hosts donation pages for charities as well as fundraiser pages. Fundraiser pages are relatively slick but minimalist – you get a single photo and some text. They don’t pass on details of donors (aside from name and amount donated), which is good from a donor perspective but might be less valuable to charities.

 

everydayhero

Fees: Annual $600+GST fee

Cut:  6.5% plus merchant transaction fees (1% to 2.45%)

Who can register: Charities, sporting clubs, schools and other organisations.

Pricing information: https://partner.help-au.everydayhero.com/hc/en-us/articles/201705937-Australia

Website: https://www.everydayhero.com/uk/

One of the larger services, everydayhero offers extremely slick fundraising pages mainly based around events and allowing the public to fundraise on your behalf. This doesn’t come cheap though – they’re one of the most expensive platforms both in terms of annual cost and per donation. Aimed mainly at larger, established charities.

 

GiveEasy

Fees: Varies by plan (None to $199 per month)

Cut:  5.5% for free, down to 2.9% for biggest plan

Who can register: Unknown

Pricing information: https://www.giveeasy.org/campaign-pricing/

Website: https://www.giveeasy.org/

Interestingly, GiveEasy offers not just a fundraising platform, but also app building and a number of other more bespoke services. They also have a tiered funding model, where you get different services depending on how much you pay monthly. The fundraising pages are relatively basic – just a logo, some text, and donation details.

 

GiveMatcher

Fees: None

Cut:  If they’re your only fundraising platform and you raise less than $5m, 0% (not including a 1.5% credit card fee). Large charities are charged 3.4% if they’re your preferred fundraising platform, 4.5% if they’re listed as an option on your fundraising page, and 6% otherwise.

Who can register: Must be a charity (registered with ACNC) as well as have an ABN

Pricing information: https://www.givematcher.com.au/faqs-for-charities

Website: https://www.givematcher.com.au/

GiveMatcher has two ways it tries to differentiate itself from the pack – a 0% charge for small charities (assuming you fundraise exclusively with them) and the fact that philanthropists can match donations. It hosts events, campaigns and fundraisers, with slick and well-produced fundraising pages where you can have updates and messages from donors. The only caveat is their strict criteria – you must be registered with the ACNC to take part.

 

GiveNow

Fees: None

Cut:  Credit card fees only (.99% for Visa and Mastercard and 1.43% for Amex.) Direct debit has no fee

Who can register: All not-for-profit and community organisations which are incorporated. No political parties or individuals.

Pricing information: https://www.givenow.com.au/about/faq

Website: https://www.givenow.com.au/

GiveNow has the honour of being the cheapest platform for charities, with no annual fees, no service fee and less than 1% credit card fees no matter what size the organisation. This is offset by the fact that they are one of the clunkier websites in terms of design. The features on offer are minimal – members of the public can’t set up fundraisers, for instance. Charities can set up a fundraising page and that’s more or less it. Then again, it is free. Great for small charities who just need somewhere to fundraise.

 

GoFundraise

Fees: Plans – from free to $230 to ‘Price on application’.

Cut:  6% fee (4.95% if you pay for the premium plan) plus 1.1% – 2.1% credit card fees

Who can register: Need to be registered Australian charity.

Pricing information: https://support.gofundraise.com/hc/en-us/articles/201282100-Signing-Up-to-GoFundraise-as-a-Charity-FAQs

Website: https://www.gofundraise.com.au/

GoFundraise is heavily focused on individual fundraisers and events. Despite a very nice homepage, the actual fundraising pages on GoFundraise aren’t actually that sharp. The events pages, which also have the option to coordinate ticket sales, are by contrast rather nice. They’ve also introduced reduced-rate fundraising pages (0.49% fee).

 

JustGiving

Fees: None

Cut:  5% fee on online donations, plus 1.65% processing fee

Who can register: Must be registered Australian charity or non-profit

Pricing information: https://pages.justgiving.com/charities.html

Website: https://www.justgiving.com/

The only international entrant, JustGiving is based in the UK but has a few Australian charities that utilise it. The charity pages are, just from personal opinion, some of the nicest I’ve seen design-wise though without donor input would look rather sparse.

 

mycause

Fees: None

Cut:  Varies by charity. Fees average 5% of gross donations, plus credit card fees

Who can register: Must be registered with the ACNC

Pricing information: https://mycause.zendesk.com/hc/en-us

Website: https://www.mycause.com.au/

mycause allows crowdfunding as well as donations, but has a heavy focus on donor-led campaigns rather than direct fundraising. Charity pages are decent, and obviously allow charities to change the colour of the page as well as the images, but the real focus in on people-to-people fundraising. The non-transparent funding model is a turn-off, as fees “average” 5% of donations, varying depending on the agreement with mycause.  You can get a 50% off discount if you put the mycause logo on your website.

 

MyGivingCircle

Fees: None

Cut:  6.5% fee plus credit card charges (usually around 1.5%)

Who can register:  Charities and not-for-profits.

Pricing information: https://mygivingcircle.org/fees/

Website: https://mygivingcircle.org/

An interesting twist on the donation page where the charities ‘compete’ to get additional funding – the more donors or donations they get, the more likely they are to win. It’s an interesting concept, see if it fits in with your fundraising strategy. The donation pages are relatively clean with a few design quirks.

 

Givebot

Fees: None

Cut:  6% fee plus credit card charges (1.4%-3%)

Who can register:  Charities

Pricing information: http://givebot.co/fees

Websitehttp://givebot.co/

Givebot is slightly different to the rest of the platforms on this list – donors pay via a chatbot in Facebook Messenger, rather than through a webpage. Charities can add a single image as well as some conversational text about their cause. Note that you will need to provide information on where the money has gone to every donor.

Sidenote: collecting online donations directly

Of course, these platforms aren’t the only way to raise money. If you’re just looking to fundraise directly, you can put a donation button on your website and avoid registering with these platforms altogether. This has some benefits, such as meaning you are more in control of the design of your fundraising page and you have more flexibility in how you fundraise. It also comes with different risks. Handling your own donations may mean more development time on your website, and depending on the platform you use may mean you need to be worried about compliance issues.

This should go without saying, but don’t put a form on your website to collect credit card information unless you’re ultra-sure that your security and compliance are 100%. If your finance team and IT team aren’t best buddies, don’t do it. PCI DSS is no joke, and if you’re found to be non-compliant you’re in a world of pain (and by pain I mean fines and sanctions, including no longer being allowed to have a bank account). If you don’t know what PCI DSS is, step away, do not pass go.

In terms of pure payment platforms the giant in the space is PayPal, which allows charities to put a simple ‘donate here’ button on their website which directly links to their bank accounts. At 2.6% (+ 30c) per donation at the lowest level and reducing to 1.1% at the top, it’s better than many of the platforms we’ve talked about above, and if you’re an ACNC registered charity they will reduce that down to 1.1%. Obviously you don’t get any of the fancier features of the platforms above (such as person-to-person fundraising) but it can be a good option.

Another potential option is Stripe, and though this is slightly more technical to install it has a substantial amount more customisability. It’s also cheaper than PayPal, at 1.75% + 30c per transaction.

 

Conclusions

From a certain perspective, it looks like we’re quibbling over small change – so what if they charge 6.5% rather than 5.5%? And yet because it’s over every transaction, those tiny discrepancies really add up. If a platform has services that you can’t do without, then by all means use them. But track it, and make sure that you’re getting more benefit than cost.

Personally, here’s some takeaways:

  • If you’re a small charity registered with the ACNC, GiveMatcher currently offers good value (i.e. free) as long as you’re willing to not list on any other platform.
  • If you’re a small non-charity, GiveNow is free and has all the essentials. This is what ChangePath has chosen, as we aren’t able to register with the ACNC.
  • Beyond that, each of the platforms have positives and negatives. There’s nothing stopping you registering on multiple platforms (well, aside from GiveMatcher’s funding scheme).

4 Comments

  1. We use CiviCRM. It’s free software to download, but you have to install it and set up hosting yourselves. We have a merchant facility with Westpac (it’s cheap for charities, seems to be about 1% cut), and we use eWAY as our payment gateway. They are probably not the only one with a charity package, but it costs us $240/year and a 1% cut on credit cards. So, if you have a significant throughput, then rolling your own system using CiviCRM or similar, with a merchant facility and a payment gateway could be a good option.

    For what it’s worth, we were using eTapestry (a product now owned by Blackbaud in the US). We wouldn’t recommend that to save ourselves. It was $600/month plus fees, slow, full of bugs and the support was awful … but then Blackbaud are infamous!

    • Hi Patrick. We’re on CiviCRM and just switching from Stripe (which has been less than functional to eWAY). I’m wondering how you got the 1% fee from eWay? Did you negotiate that we eWay or direct with your bank? Thanks!

  2. Hi Sam, very clear and concise list. I hope you don’t mind me adding our platform to your list – we’ll you’ll delete this if you do! 🙂

    MyGivingCircle
    Fees : None
    Cut : 6.5% + credit card fees at cost
    Who can register: Not-for-profits and Charities

    Website: https://mygivingcircle.org

    We do donor-matching to encourage regular giving and run cause-based Giving Circles where we provide prizes to the charities and not-for-profits with the most votes. This encourages supporters to vote, donate and advocate for their favourite charities and (we hope!) helps charities raise more money.

  3. The Givematcher site sounds great but won’t load (on multiple devices) and haven’t responded to a message on facebook – are they still active? Thanks

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

*

© 2017 The ChangePath Blog

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑